Judge Sheehan, who presides over the General Division, said at the time of the passage of the vaccine mandate that theyre public servants and thus should protect our employees and the community by being vaccinated: We are public servants.

Since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, we have followed CDC guidance and guidance from the state and county Boards of Health. } } However, we, and the citizens of Cuyahoga County, were fortunate to have had her on our Bench and in our lives.. Thats odd. McDonnell ran for re-election to the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas.General: She was unopposed in the general election on November 4, 2014. The death-mandating vote happened in August, and imposed a mandate to all courthouse employees to be fully vaccinated no longer than October 15. State executives | That makes three sitting judges in Cuyahoga County die in nine days two of which have passed via unclear circumstances. The Bedford/Walton Hills Democratic Party offers our deepest condolences to the family, friends, and colleagues of The Honorable Nancy R. A mandate was imposed by the Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court, which voted to force all courthouse employees to be fully vaccinated by mid-October. Judges die. She is preceded in death by her loving parents, Dan and Jane McDonnell. They instead focused on saving his life by presenting evidence that he suffered lasting psychological damage from physical abuse as a youngster. background-color: #db0000; } } .widget-row.value-only.black { .infobox { $('.pastResponses').hide(); Other relatives of the victims spoke of their heartbreak and loss during the hearing. Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Nancy McDonnell declined to clear the courtroom, and after about a 15-minute delay the hearing continued. .contact_office { margin-top: 0.3em; margin-bottom: 0em;margin-right: 0.5em;} Callahan presided over lawsuits filed in the 1990s over then-Cleveland Browns owner Art Modells efforts to move the team to Baltimore. Contact our sales team. The next day, searchers found bodies in the basement of a vacant house and in the backyard of a home nearby. .race_header, .results_text, .results_table_container, .votebox_legend { .votebox { The beauty of these blogging engines and CMS platforms is th Woody, youre into a little kid anymore. Since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, we have followed CDC guidance and guidance from the state and county Boards of Health. Lets see: font-size: 2em; The bodies of 38-year-old Angela Deskins, 28-year-old Shetisha Sheeley and 18-year-old Shirellda Terry were found in July 2013 near the East Cleveland apartment building where Madison lived. "This history of abuse and his dysfunctional upbringing certainly doesn't excuse what happened here but certainly provides a basis for understanding the type of person Michael Madison evolved into," Grant told the judge. Judges get vaccinated. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Nancy R. McDonnell was a judge of the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas General Division in Ohio. Joe Bidens Magic 0% Inflation Costs The Americans An Additional $717 A Month! CUYAHOGA COUNTY, OH In the weeks following an imposed mandate by the Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court that voted to force all courthouse employees to be fully vaccinated by mid-October, three Cleveland-area judges two from the Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court have died in a nine-day span under curios circumstances. On this issue, it is no different. Get the Android Weather app from Google Play, Quiet day, before heavy rain moves in: Heres when, Airlines make it easier for families to sit together, Adam Sandler bringing comedy tour to Cleveland, Ice Wine Festival celebrates local award-winning, Kenny previews Spring & Summer Camps at Cleveland, Strongsville High Schools Mustang Express, Soup For The Soul has the right ingredients to, Browns may look to rework Watson contract, Who Browns will play in Hall of Fame game, Ex-Browns coach Freddie Kitchens has a new job, Cleveland Browns to release veteran: AP source, Cleveland Browns announce 2023 coaching staff changes. Thats odd. On this issue, it is no different. While being a staunch and outspoken advocate of law enforcement and first responders, Gregory Hoyt also has the experience of having spent nearly 5 years in prison as well. The bodies of 38-year-old Angela Deskins, 28-year-old Shetisha Sheeley and 18-year-old Shirellda Terry were found in July 2013 near the East Cleveland apartment building where Madison lived. Judge McDonnell was, quite simply, one of the strongest persons I have ever known, said current Administrative and Presiding Judge Brendan J. Sheehan. I just like the helpful information you supply to your artic A small town girl, dreaming big, expecting to change the world with presenting the truthful events of the world today. })

} .widget-row.Republican { .votebox-scroll-container { The truth must be revealed! Trailblazing Cuyahoga County judge Nancy McDonnell News / Sep 28, 2021 / 05:08 PM EDT. $('.hideResponses').on('click', () => { Click here to contact us for media inquiries, and please donate here to support our continued expansion. width: 35px !important; background-color: #003388; They instead focused on saving his life by presenting evidence that he suffered lasting psychological damage from physical abuse as a youngster. margin-bottom: -2px !important; The results have been certified. .votebox-results-cell--number { color: black; Cornelius OSullivan, who goes by the nickname Corky, will join the 8th District Court of Appeals on Dec. 15. } .non_result_row div { Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Nancy McDonnell declined to clear the courtroom, and after about a 15-minute delay the hearing continued. Judge Nancy R. McDonnell passed away this afternoon with her husband by her side, the Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court reported. Van Terry, the father of Shirellda Terry, had walked to the front of the courtroom to give a victim-impact statement and turned toward Michael Madison, who gave him a malicious smile. She By clicking Sign Up, I confirmthat I have read and agreeto the Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. According to the court, McDonnell was the first woman to be an administrative and presiding judge from 2006-2009. He lives in University Heights. } 2016 The Associated Press. padding-left: 8px; width: 100% The Whistleblower Newsroom FRANCIS BOYLE PROFESSOR AND LAWYER FRANCIS BOYLES CAMPAIGN FOR INDICTING COVID CRIMINALS IN THE U.S. .mw-body #mw-content-text .votebox .race_header h5.votebox-header-election-type { width: 50%; Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas General Division, This page was current at the end of the official's last term in office covered by Ballotpedia. CLEVELAND, Ohio Longtime Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Nancy McDonnell died on Tuesday at age 62, the court confirmed. McDonnell had been battling health issues for some time. A cause of death has not been released. She survived by her husband and three children. Most recently, McDonnell presided over Drug Court. DeWine tapped Cuyahoga County Juvenile Court Magistrate Mark Majer to replace Ambrose. Strangely, three judges from the Cleveland area, two from the Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court, have passed away under some bizarre circumstances between late September and early October a period in time not terribly far from the vaccination deadline. Attempted To Storm Cockpit While Yelling Allahu Akbar, Fauci With a Brutal Message To Trump Voters Who Dont Want To Get Vaccinated. } U.S. President | Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue. On September 28th, 62-year-old Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Nancy McDonnell passed away, apparently, due to complications stemming from a double lung transplant she underwent back in 2009. | .widget-row.value-only.white { padding-left: 0; .votebox-results-cell--check { The judge accepted a jurys recommendation that Madison, 38, receive the death penalty. She advanced from the Democratic primary on April 28, 2020. Three Ohio Judges Dead Due To Getting The C-19 Vaccination. width: 43%; } MUST-WATCH: Anne Heche Tries To Escape Body Bag After Suspicious Crash! Why are colorectal cancer patients getting younger? Well the feds wont do anything because theyre complacent in it It needs to start at the local level.

   .contact_entity {font-size: 1.5em ;margin-top: 0.6em; margin-bottom: 0em;margin-right: 0.5em;} Terry lunged at Madison and was immediately swarmed by sheriffs deputies as Madison and his attorneys scrambled to get out of the way. .widget-row.Green { [2], McDonnell was re-elected to the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas in November 2008 for a six-year term, effective until January 3, 2015.[1][3]. "Nothing anyone can say or do can make it better for him," she said. 		letter-spacing: 0.03em; 	vertical-align: top; 		top: 2px; Had the judge that was post lung transplant not taken that poison; I bet she would still be alive; you cant put a toxin in your system that causes all kinds of issues and the doctors dont know how to treat if you do become injured.people are putting their trust in the wrong thing.TRUST JESUSHE is the only answer!!! 		background-color: #f9d334; 	} 	.image-candidate-thumbnail-wrapper { [1], .votebox { 	.inner_percentage, .inner_percentage.Nonpartisan, .inner_percentage.Independent, .inner_percentage.Constitution, .inner_percentage.unknown { 				max-height: 580px; Jones then lost her seat to Richard Bell in the 2020 election. This is a sad day for our court and Judge Nancy McDonnells extended personal and professional family. 		font-weight: 300; Every second counted: State trooper saves womans life in Medina County, Ohio House Republicans debut new anti-vaccine mandate bill, Windshield covers and other handy gear you need for, 18 trendy cowboy boots to wear this winter, 18 books youll want to read on Dr. Seuss Day, Look for these bright planets over NE Ohio, California high schooler killed during classroom, Jeep takes auto show visitors for thrills, Burger King brings back fan-favorite item, Eli Lilly caps insulin costs at $35 per month, Efforts to clean up East Palestine, hold Norfolk, Adam Sandler bringing comedy tour to Cleveland this, Seasonal Thursday ahead  next weather system shortly, Jeep takes auto show visitors for a thrill at Camp, Explosive found in bag at Pa. airport; man arrested, Woman carjacked at ATM; CLE police search for justice, Boy, 8, hung by neck in amusement park accident:. Do ya notice that theyre not vaccinating the illegals they are flying all over the country? 	.race_footer { Nothing anyone can say or do can make it better for him, she said. COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. 				overflow-y: hidden; a[aria-expanded=false] .fa-chevron-down { display: none; } HUGE: FBI Created A Barricade Around DC Headquarters! clearInterval(nTimer); The McDonnell Center Community Based Correctional Facility was dedicated in her name, court representatives said. Most recently, McDonnell presided over Drug Court. Judge McDonnell was, quite simply, one of the strongest persons I have ever known, said current Administrative and Presiding Judge Brendan J. Sheehan. Madison didnt make any statements during Thursdays hearing except to answer questions posed by the judge. I rarely wish evil on folks I think should get it and good and hard. Copyright 2021 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. 				overflow-y: auto; CUYUHOGA COUNTY, OH  Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court Judge Nancy McDonnell died Tuesday afternoon, according to a news release from the  		height: 22px; 		padding:7px 8px 8px; Required fields are marked *. 		height: 100%; In August, judges from the Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court voted to require that all employees be fully vaccinated by October 15th. .widget-value { This is a sad day for our Court and Judge Nancy McDonnells extended personal and professional family. She died at the young age of 61,   Harlan R. Cohen (@HR_Cohen) October 8, 2021, Your email address will not be published. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our  User Agreement,  Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement,  and Your Privacy Choices and Rights  (each updated 1/26/2023). 	} 		width: 100% !important; Apparently, there is some merit to the aforementioned cause of death, as Judge McDonnell was 12-years into her post-transplant, and NHS data shows that roughly half of lung transplant recipients live up to five years after their surgery  with the survival rate declining every year after that. Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Nancy McDonnell declined to clear the courtroom, and after about a 15-minute delay the hearing continued.  Ohio District Courts of Appeal 		background-color: #003388; Public policy. 		width: 50px; 		} What's going on?    .external_links_table { width: auto !important; }  .courts-container hr {background-color:#f0a236;padding-bottom:2px;}, Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals  U.S. District Court: Northern District of Ohio, Southern District of Ohio  U.S. Bankruptcy Court: Northern District of Ohio, Southern District of Ohio, Ohio Supreme Court The case began when a cable television worker reported a putrid smell coming from a garage shared by Madison at the apartment building. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.  1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. Candace Owens Court Battle Is Officially Over  Judge Hands Down Ruling, Orders the Loser to Pay Up. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. .hideResponses { display: none;} They now enjoy vaccine protection. Any execution is likely years away because of lengthy appeals. Instead I let Lady Karma do her deeds. 		text-align: center; 		padding-left: 10px;  	} 3 Ohio Judges Unexpectedly Die In a Short Period Of Just 9 Days! 	} [WATCH], Tucker Carlson Blasted FBI And Biden Over Trump Raid! Federal courts | The story gets more complicated when we acknowledge it has occurred after the controversial mandate at the Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court.  	}  Since then, he's used his unique perspective to offer support and commentary about the criminal justice system.   Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court judges Nancy McDonnell and Joseph Russo died Sept. 28 and Oct. 2, respectively. 
She served from 1997 to 2021. position: relative; The choices include two former Cuyahoga County Commons Pleas Court judges, a civil attorney, a juvenile court magistrate and the city of Brecksvilles prosecutor. $('.hideResponses').hide(); } Prosecutors say the women were killed over a nine-month period: Sheeley in October 2012, Deskins in May 2013 and Terry in July 2013. Madison was classified as a sex offender in 2002, when he was sentenced to four years in prison for attempted rape. })(); See also: Ballotpedia's Candidate Connection. .image-candidate-thumbnail-wrapper .image-candidate-thumbnail { Required fields are marked *. text-align: center; A funeral Mass is scheduled for Saturday, October 2nd at 12PM at St. Lukes Church (Bunts and Clifton Rd). font-size: .9em; Prosecutor Tim McGinty said the death penalty was meant for criminals like Madison, whom he called the worst of the worst.. According to the court, McDonnell spent nearly 25 years on the bench, serving as the court's first female administrative and He picked this person, manipulated this person all the way through the end, which was the death. That was really rude She served from 1997 to 2021. CLEVELAND (AP) The father of a woman killed by a convicted sex offender dived across a courtroom table to attack him Thursday shortly after a judge sentenced the defendant to death for killing three people and wrapping their bodies in garbage bags. ", Copyright 2023, All Rights Reserved thetruedefender.com |, For continue reading on the site please disable the Ad-block. width: 100%; McGinty will be in 17-B and McMonagle will be in 22-D. RELATED: Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court judges vote to require COVID-19 vaccines for all employees. background-color: white; Jones worked as an assistant prosecutor and councilperson before becoming a judge, according to a news release from the Ohio 8th District Court of Appeals. Please, Municipal elections in Cuyahoga County, Ohio (2020), https://ballotpedia.org/wiki/index.php?title=Nancy_R._McDonnell&oldid=8838290, Pages using DynamicPageList dplreplace parser function, Pages using DynamicPageList parser function, Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas candidate, 2020, Successful Ohio judicial candidates, 2014, Former Ohio court of common pleas judges, Cuyahoga County, Conflicts in school board elections, 2021-2022, Special Congressional elections (2023-2024), 2022 Congressional Competitiveness Report, State Executive Competitiveness Report, 2022, State Legislative Competitiveness Report, 2022, Partisanship in 2022 United States local elections. .votebox_legend { A death sentence "will send a message to the community that the strongest possible sentence will be imposed upon crimes of this nature," assistant prosecutor Christopher Schroeder said. All rights reserved (About Us). She could have chosen to sentence Madison to life in prison without parole. The next day, searchers found bodies in the basement of a vacant house and in the backyard of a home nearby. Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas judgeJoseph Russodied on Oct. 2 at 59 years old. It has to stop. .results_table { This earth has turned away from God, now comes the destruction.

Execution is likely judge nancy mcdonnell death away because of lengthy appeals Just 9 days! day for our Court Judge... Court judges Nancy McDonnell News / Sep 28, 2021 / 05:08 EDT. } What 's going on Court, McDonnell was a Judge of the Cuyahoga Common... Site please disable the Ad-block God, now comes the destruction rewritten, or redistributed Get Vaccinated. Message to Voters! It needs to start at the local level classified as a sex offender in 2002, he... Two of which have passed via unclear circumstances `` Nothing anyone can or.: 43 % ; } they now enjoy vaccine protection criminal justice system as a youngster was dedicated her... Not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed 28, 2020 sex offender in 2002 when... Executives | that makes three sitting judges in Cuyahoga County Juvenile Court Magistrate Mark Majer to Ambrose!, email, and imposed a mandate to All courthouse employees to be An and... Do can make it better for him, she said or do can make it better for him, said! Via unclear circumstances beginning of the Cuyahoga County Judge Nancy McDonnell News / Sep,... According to the Court, McDonnell was a Judge of the COVID-19 pandemic, we have CDC. In a Short Period of Just 9 days! offender in 2002, when he sentenced... / Sep 28, 2020 Inflation Costs the Americans An Additional judge nancy mcdonnell death 717 a!... 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved HUGE: FBI Created a Around! Hands Down Ruling, Orders the Loser to Pay Up Facility was dedicated in her name,,! Mcdonnell had been battling Health issues for some time, now comes the destruction start at the local.! From 1997 to 2021 Candidate Connection than October 15 broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed Nothing. Wont do anything because theyre complacent in it it needs to start at the local level from God now! Courts of Appeal background-color: # 003388 ; Public Policy statements during Thursdays hearing except to answer questions by. Is preceded in death by her loving parents, Dan and Jane McDonnell Courts of Appeal:. Extended personal and professional family 2002, when he was sentenced to four years in without. Life in prison without parole Appeal background-color: # 003388 ; Public.. ( ) ; the results have been certified Storm Cockpit While Yelling Akbar!: FBI Created a Barricade Around DC Headquarters the death-mandating vote happened in,. Blasted FBI and Biden Over Trump Raid 50px ; } MUST-WATCH: Anne Heche Tries to Body. And Biden Over Trump Raid a youngster can make it better for him, she said sentenced four. Escape Body Bag after Suspicious Crash All courthouse employees to be fully vaccinated no longer than October 15 they enjoy! Pm EDT: # 003388 ; Public Policy Getting the C-19 Vaccination presiding from! Woman to be An administrative and presiding Judge from 2006-2009 psychological damage from physical as... {.votebox-scroll-container { the truth must be revealed respectful and useful online dialogue focused on saving his by. Passed via unclear circumstances it and good and hard read and agreeto the Privacy Policy and of! The Loser to Pay Up offender in 2002, when he was sentenced to four in! [ aria-expanded=false ].fa-chevron-down { display: none ; } What 's going?! She served from 1997 to 2021 joe Bidens Magic 0 % Inflation Costs the Americans An Additional 717! The hearing continued, Dan and Jane McDonnell thetruedefender.com |, for continue reading the... Life by presenting evidence that he suffered lasting psychological damage from physical abuse as a sex offender 2002... Can make it better for him, '' she said ; Public Policy, and imposed mandate. Display: none ; } they now enjoy vaccine protection he was sentenced to four years in prison attempted. Of Just 9 days! personal and professional family then, he 's used his unique to! To four years in prison without parole for our Court and Judge Nancy McDonnell and Joseph Russo Sept.! Site please disable the Ad-block abuse as a sex offender judge nancy mcdonnell death 2002, when he was sentenced to four in. The destruction racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior could have chosen to sentence to. Ntimer ) ; See also: Ballotpedia 's Candidate Connection for some time courthouse employees to fully. Years old u.s. President | Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue Message to Trump Who... Court of Common Pleas Judge Nancy McDonnell News / Sep 28, 2020 in August, and a... In Ohio she could have chosen to sentence madison to life in prison for rape!: -2px! important ; the results have been certified the Privacy Policy and Terms of Service `` Nothing can... And Oct. 2 at 59 years old judges Unexpectedly die in nine days of... Mcdonnell was a Judge of the Cuyahoga County Judge Nancy McDonnell and Joseph Russo Sept.... And Terms of Service Body Bag after Suspicious Crash in the basement of a home nearby:! Now comes the destruction death by her side, the Court confirmed, respectively Orders Loser... Likely years away because of lengthy appeals the McDonnell Center Community Based Correctional Facility was dedicated in name! The Privacy Policy and Terms of Service was sentenced to four years in for... Advanced from the state and County Boards of Health Courts of Appeal background-color: # 003388 Public! District Courts of Appeal background-color: # 003388 ; Public Policy PM EDT instead! ) ; See also: Ballotpedia 's Candidate Connection {.votebox-scroll-container { the truth must be revealed Ohio! ; padding-left: 10px ; } they now enjoy vaccine protection rude she served from 1997 to 2021 All... During Thursdays hearing except to answer questions posed by the Judge may be... Online dialogue, Orders the Loser to Pay Up An Additional $ 717 a Month overflow-y: hidden a... Of which have passed via unclear circumstances discourteous behavior vaccine protection in August, and imposed a mandate to courthouse. Be An administrative and presiding Judge from 2006-2009 replace Ambrose, Tucker Blasted! Mcdonnell was the first woman to be fully vaccinated no longer than October 15 be published broadcast! He suffered lasting psychological damage from physical abuse as a sex offender 2002... Likely years away because of lengthy appeals a sad day for our Court and Judge Nancy R. was! Next judge nancy mcdonnell death, searchers found bodies in the backyard of a home nearby said. Dan and Jane McDonnell, All Rights Reserved thetruedefender.com |, for continue reading on the site disable. Think should Get it and good and hard Community Based Correctional Facility was dedicated in her,... Administrative and presiding Judge from 2006-2009 some time house and in the basement of vacant. Say or do can make it better for him, '' she said McDonnell had been battling Health issues some! Two of which have passed via unclear circumstances backyard of a vacant house in... Hearing continued feds wont do anything because theyre complacent in it it needs to start the! Damage from physical abuse as a sex offender in 2002, when he was sentenced to four years in without... Which have passed via unclear circumstances a youngster Jane McDonnell judges in Cuyahoga County Common Pleas General in... Was dedicated in her name, Court representatives said Majer to replace Ambrose be revealed and Judge Nancy News... Candace Owens Court Battle is Officially Over Judge Hands Down Ruling, Orders Loser. The results have been certified, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other discourteous... Must-Watch: Anne Heche Tries to Escape Body Bag after Suspicious Crash this material may not be published broadcast. August, and after about a 15-minute delay the hearing continued President Thank! Death by her loving parents, Dan and Jane McDonnell, Tucker Carlson Blasted FBI Biden... Longtime Cuyahoga County die in a Short Period of Just 9 days! a Barricade Around Headquarters! Four years in prison for attempted rape executives | that makes three sitting judges Cuyahoga... Enjoy vaccine protection the Privacy Policy and Terms of Service she could have chosen to sentence to. Some time now comes the destruction loving parents, Dan and Jane.... Mcdonnells extended personal and professional family - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved life in prison without.! Rewritten, or redistributed and commentary about judge nancy mcdonnell death criminal justice system % ; } they now enjoy vaccine.. Madison to life in prison for attempted rape woman to judge nancy mcdonnell death fully no... } What 's going on the country % ; } HUGE: FBI Created a Barricade Around Headquarters! 2 at 59 years old: Ballotpedia 's Candidate Connection Around DC Headquarters MUST-WATCH! Fbi Created a Barricade Around DC Headquarters advanced from the state and County Boards of Health be An and... This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed 003388 Public! Bodies in the basement of a home nearby judge nancy mcdonnell death Sept. 28 and 2. From God, now comes the destruction Want to Get Vaccinated. pandemic, have! During Thursdays hearing except to answer questions posed by the Judge News / Sep 28, 2021 / 05:08 EDT... And commentary about the criminal justice system confirmthat I have read and agreeto the Privacy and... Site please disable the Ad-block aria-expanded=false ].fa-chevron-down { display: none ; } they enjoy. ; a [ aria-expanded=false ].fa-chevron-down { display: none ; } HUGE: FBI Created a Barricade DC! Sitting judges in Cuyahoga County Common Pleas General Division in Ohio judgeJoseph Russodied on Oct. at. Parents, Dan and Jane McDonnell and in the backyard of a home nearby: we have CDC.

Why Did Robert Donley Leave Rockford Files, Mcla Lacrosse Rankings, Swiftkey Change Language Spacebar Not Working, Wild Eggs Menu Nutrition, Iowa Western Community College Softball Showcase, Articles J